India’s Kashmir Policy: Way Forward

Ram Puniyani    2017-05-02

The turmoil in Kashmir, which got intensified after the fake encounter of Burhan Wani (July 2016), does not seem to abet. It has been worsening as reflected in the ongoing violence leading to low turnout of voters in the by poll (April 2017). Shockingly there was a turn out only of 7.14 percent of voters. The by-polls were also marred by violence in which, many a civilians and security force person also died and lately one witnessed with great horror a Kashmir youth being tied to the military truck to prevent stone pelters from throwing stones on the vehicle.
. Those pelting stones don’t seem to be stopping despite the lapse of period of time. These young men are being looked at in various ways. Farookh Abdullah had stated on the eve of elections that those young men throwing stones are doing so for their nation. This statement of his came under scathing criticism from various quarters and section of media and was dismissed by many as a pre election statement.
Another way of looking at those pelting stones; as gleaned from section of media; is that these are pro-Pakistan elements. They are being instigated by Pakistan and that they are doing this for money. As such stone pelting has been used as a method of protest in Kashmir since ages but has become glaringly obvious from last few years. Intimidated by the terrorists-militants on one side and the security forces on the other these young men have been resorting to pelting stones as a form of protest and anguish. One can see the clear pattern in worsening repression and an increase in their activities. As such after every major act of hanging-murder the protests have become more intense e.g. after the hanging of Maqbul Butt (1984), then after the hanging of Afzal Guru (2013) and now after the killing of Burhan Wani (2016).
Who are these boys who pelt stones? Are these merely Pakistan inspired and funded youth? In the aftermath of state crackdown; hundreds have died, thousands have been wounded and many more have lost eyesight! A section of TV and other media is going hammer and tongs about the role of Pakistan and the funding they receive. The question which needs to be introspected is that will young people risk their life, loss of eyesight or other harm to body just for someone’s bidding or some money? Many of them are teenagers, tech savvy and they are so much full of deep hatred that they are willing to risk their lives, not caring about their future. The degree of frustration among them must we horrific.
Only a small section of media has gone deeper into the issue and have interviewed some of them. The stories of their experiences and feelings shatter one’s perceptions about law and order in Kashmir. Many belong to families which have given up hope of any type. Most of these young boys have experienced torture, beating, harassments of sorts and often humiliation For many of them stone throwing comes as sort of catharsis, a feeling of having taken revenge of what has happened to them. It is the only strong way of protest they must be feeling is left for them. Many of them are Pro Pakistan for sure but the basic point remains political alienation which is seeping in deepening. This in turn is due to the suffering and pain to which Kashmir has been subjected due to the prolonged military presence in the area.
Post Burhan Wani murder, the Kashmir based PDP, or even national Conference has been able to see the intensity of the situation. Mahbooba Mufti, the Chief Minister of the ruling coalition, wanted to go for a dialogue with the dissenters, but coalition partner and the party leading at center BJP shot down the idea. Mahbooba Mufti felt that dialogue is the only way out but BJP feels that dialogue is a way to befool the people. It seems the ruling BJP wants to take a hard line to deal with dissidence, regards that dissidence is there only due to Pakistan or ISIS and so repression should be intensified.
What have earlier efforts for peace which need to be recalled in the present damning times? In one of the most significant move UPA II had appointed a team of interlocutors to understand and suggest the way out. The eminent team suggested that the autonomy of Kashmir Assembly, which is part of treaty of accession, be restored, dialogue with dissidents to be initiated and also talks with Pakistan be undertaken along with repeal of Armed Forces Special Powers Act.
Today there can be two approaches one is to recall the treaty of accession and gravitate towards that and take the recommendations of Interlocutors seriously. Nearly seven decades after the accession of Kashmir to India, there is a need to recall that forcible merger; repression of dissent was never the idea of founders of Indian nation. Let’s see what Sardar Vallabhbhai Patel had to say on the matter way back, Deputy Prime Minister Vallabhbhai Patel said at a public meeting in Bombay on October 30, 1948: “Some people consider that a Muslim majority area must necessarily belong to Pakistan. They wonder why we are in Kashmir. The answer is plain and simple. We are in Kashmir because the people of Kashmir want us to be there. The moment we realize that the people of Kashmir do not want us to be there, we shall not be there even for a minute… We shall not let the Kashmir down” (The Hindustan Times, October 31, 1948).
The situation in Kashmir is critical, and worsening by the day due to the high handed dealings from the center. Even the Chief Minister of Kashmir and the people like Sheikh Abdulla need to be listened to, if we want peace in the green valley, peace which is crucial. The deeper peace can only be won through winning the hearts and minds of the people of Kashmir, ultranationalist formulations don’t work in the long run.

গৌতম বন্দ্যোপাধ্যায়,2017-05-06

বৈশাখের প্রবল নিদাঘেও শান্তির বারি মাহালি এবং মণ্ডল পরিবারে-সেই নকশালবাড়ি থেকে এই চেতলায়। দেখে মনে হচ্ছে, মোদি-মমতার দ্বৈরথের দরুন এবার প্রাচীন একটি প্রবচন পাল্টে ফেলার সময় এসেছে। এখন থেকে হয়তো বলতে হবে, রাজায় রাজায় যুদ্ধ হয় নলখাগড়ারা প্রাণ পায়। ....

গৌতম বন্দ্যোপাধ্যায়,2017-04-24

এরকমটিই তো হওয়ার কথা ছিল। অশান্ত কাশ্মীরে একটি নতুন কালো মেঘের আবির্ভাবে সে সত্যই ফের প্রতিভাত হল। ন’বছরের এক বালিকাকে গোরক্ষকেরা প্রহারেণ ধনঞ্জয় করে বুঝিয়েছে, এ দেশে গোমাতাকে চারণভূমিতেও নিয়ে যাওয়া যাবে না, যদি না, কট্টর হিন্দুবাহিনীদের কাছ থেকে শংসাপত্র না .....

N Sathiya Moorthy,2017-04-21

To elect, or re-elect a chief minister, the AIADMK needs to call only the MLAs for a meeting. But to elect a new general secretary, it would have to conduct direct elections with all registered cadres participating and voting. And that is .....

Ram Puniyani,2017-04-10

The spectacular victory of BJP in UP Assembly poll was capped by choosing of Adityanath Yogi as the Chief Minister of UP. He had not contested for the Assembly nor was he projected as the Chief Minister by BJP before polls. Why ....

Ram Puniyani,2017-04-08

After the long wait, the Supreme Court Chief Justice J.S. Khehar opined that long pending dispute of Ram Janmabhoomi-Babri Masjid should be settled out of court. (March 2017) He even offered to mediate himself in the matter.

গৌতম রায়,2017-03-23

উত্তরপ্রদেশের ভোটের প্রচার পর্বে সামাজিক মেরুকরণের ভিতর দিয়ে এমন একটা পরিবেশ গোটা হিন্দুত্ববাদী শিবির রচনা করে যে, কেবলমাত্র হিন্দু সম্প্রদায়েরই সংখ্যাগরিষ্ঠ অংশ বিজেপিকে ভোট দিয়েছে তা নয়।সংখ্যালঘু মুসলমান সমাজের একটা বড়ো অংশ ও ভোটের বাক্সে নিরাশ করে নি ....

Ram Puniyani,2017-03-22

The Assembly election results of 2017 have come as a bolt to many and are a matter of deep celebration for the communal forces. While there is a slight dip in the voting percentage of BJP from 2014 general elections, the number of seats it ...

গৌতম রায়,2017-03-16

সংখ্যালঘু অধ্যুষিত এলাকাগুলিতে বিজেপি প্রার্থীর জয় উত্তরপ্রদেশ বিধানসভা ভোটের ফলাফলে সব থেকে লক্ষণীয় বিষয়। বিজেপি গত ২০১৪র লোকসভা ভোটের সময়ে উত্তরপ্রদেশে একজন সংখ্যালঘুকেও দলীয় টিকিট দেয় নি।এই ভাবশার পিছনে সেদিন সবথেকে বেশি কাজ করেছিল অমিত ....

স্টাফ রাইটার,2017-02-28

মালয়ালম যাজক মহিলাদের পোশাক সম্পর্কে যা বলেছেন সে সম্পর্কে কিছু প্রশ্ন রইল তাঁর কাছে। পোশাক কি? ও কেন পড়া হয়? প্রাকৃতিক পরিবেশ থেকে মানুষ নিজেকে বাঁচানোর জন্য এক সময় পোশাক পড়তো। তারপর সময়ের পরিবর্তনের সঙ্গে সঙ্গে পোশাকেরও বিবর্তন হয়েছে। ক্ষমতা অনুযায়ী.....

স্টাফ রাইটার,2017-02-25

নরেন্দ্র মোদী তামিলনাড়ুর পশ্চিমে নীলগিড়ি পাহাড়ের কাছেই কোয়েমবাটুরে ১১৩ ফুট উচু শিবের মূর্তির আবক্ষ উন্মোচন করতে গিয়ে ৫০০ বিক্ষোভকারির সম্মুখীন হয়েছেন। আধিকারিকেরা জানিয়েছেন বিক্ষোভকারিরা কালো বেলুনও উড়িয়ে জানিয়ে দিয়েছে পরিবেশের রক্ষাকারী কমিটির বিরুদ্ধাচারণ...